Milliways

TrustMeRelay? Investigating Apple's iCloud Private Relay

Apple strongly emphasizes the security and privacy of its devices and services. I analyze the dual-hop architecture, deployed protocols, and inner workings of their privacy-centric, VPN/Tor-alike service iCloud Private Relay. I will talk about my reverse engineering process and falsify Apple's privacy by design and access control claims.
Apple's iCloud Private Relay is a novel Internet privacy service allowing users to securely and privately browse the Internet. It is directly implemented into Apple's operating systems and included with all iCloud+ subscriptions. Compared to traditional VPN services, Private Relay's dual-hop architecture separates the knowledge of the user's IP address and their destination website between two different Relays. Apple operates the first Relay while the second one is by one of its four partners: Akamai, CloudFlare, or Fastly. Apple claims its architecture enforces enhanced protection of users' privacy ("privacy by design") while still providing a high-performance browsing experience. Their president of software engineering, Craig Federighi, even mentions that Apple does not want users to have trust in them. Further, the company claims its service incorporates anti-abuse and fraud prevention mechanisms. As Private Relay validates any connection at the account and device level, website operators can trust them. I reverse engineer Private Relay's macOS implementation, present its involved technical components and how they collaborate. With that gained knowledge, I analyze authentication and authorization mechanisms deployed by Private Relay regarding potential ways of abuse. Furthermore, I review the privacy claims regarding the architecture and its deployment.

Additional information

Live Stream https://streaming.media.ccc.de/camp2023/milliways
Type Talk
Language English

More sessions

8/15/23
Milliways
Hardware Hacking Village
In this 2h workshop, I will teach you to work with the tiny components that modern electronic devices are made of. We will assemble an electronic kitten, that purrs when touched correctly, and hisses when touched wrong. It will work, and is guaranteed to remove your fear of hand-assembling surface mount designs.
8/15/23
Milliways
Milliways
The session proposes a quick overview of Frida, a dynamic instrumentation framework, and how it can be used to enhance our work during the runtime analysis of a mobile application. It will be a walkthrough on how hooking and rewriting functions in runtime may be helpful against anti-reverse engineering measures and SSL pinning mechanisms.
8/15/23
Milliways
Milliways
Hardware FIDO U2F tokens are security devices which are meant to defend user second factor keys from physical and remote attacks. In this presentation different security features and implemented by FIDO U2F tokens and how they are meant to protect a user from various attack scenarios. We will focus on the open source implementation of FIDO U2F token developed and Common Criteria certified by Federal Office for Information Security (BSI). Having access not only to the source code of the token ...
8/15/23
Milliways
Milliways Workshop Dome
Come learn how to hack networks without needing to piss off your housemates, local coffee shop, or the Feds! Bring your laptop and by the end of this workshop, everyone can walk away having intercepted some packets and popped some reverse shells.
8/15/23
Milliways
Milliways
MITRE ATT&CK (Attack Framework among friends) is intimidating sight at first, but is a great tool for risk identification, threat analysis, red teaming, DFIR and security management. Brief introduction to the topic with various examples.
8/15/23
Milliways
Hardware Hacking Village
Solder your own pathlighter badge to illuminate your surroundings at night.
8/15/23
Milliways
Milliways
This talk will show you how many interfaces have to communicate in order to fly experiments on a sounding rocket. We will give you insights into the procedures and the complexity of a research campaign and the actual flight of the rocket itself. In particular, we look at the hardware and software used in the Ground Support Equipment (GSE) and the Service Module (SM) within the rocket.