Ethics, Politics & Society

Decolonize runet! Decolonize network measurements! A provocative take on the Russian sovereign internet project

Saal Granville
Xenia
This talk proposes to look at the russian "sovereign internet" project from a decolonialist point of view. First, it provides an analysis of a corpus of Telegram channels of indigenous, decolonialist and regionalist movements to map the growing space of "post-Russian" discourses. Secondly, it suggests to consider inequalities of access to information and connectivity across different territories of the so-called Russian Federation. Looking at past events of local/regional internet shutdowns. It describes the so-called Runet not as a homogeneous space, but actually a multitude of different "lived experiences". It proposes a framework to analyze regional shutdown-resilience and understand how Russia has been tightening its control on specific regions.
This talk proposes to look at the russian "sovereign internet" project from a decolonialist point of view. This interdisciplinary research is based on almost 6 years of fieldwork, combining network measurements, open data from IODA, OONI, Censored Planet, as well as OSINT investigations, analysis of legal texts, in-depth interviews and web-ethnography. To understand the decolonialist discourses and movements, we have also analyzed Telegram as an environment where these discourses are being multiplied since the beginning of the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. With colleagues from Raspad.Network we scraped and analyzed a corpus of Telegram channels dedicated to regionalist, indigenous, local agenda and visualized connections and disparities between different indigenous and regionalist movements. We tried to distinguish between grassroots groups and curated organizations tied to larger orchestrated disinformation campaigns. In our talk we will showcase some of the highlights from this study and share some visualizations based on graph analysis that will help the audience to learn more about the multitude of decolonialist movements within Russia. The talk proposes to consider inequalities of access to information and connectivity across different territories of the so-called Russian Federation. Looking at past events of local/regional internet shutdowns — starting from informational annexation of Crimea in 2014, followed by the remarkable shutdowns in 2018 in Ingushetia, as well as more recent events in Dagestan and other less "mediatized" shutdown or throttling cases, we argue that the so-called Runet is not a homogeneous space, but actually a multitude of different "lived experiences". It is well-known in the space of internet science that Russia has a diverse ISP space and counts more than 3500 Internet Service Providers. However, it is much less noticed that these ISPs are not equally distributed across the territory, and not without consequence. We argue that the so-called "Tcheburnet" (a commonly used term for "Russian autonomous and sovereign Internet" project) is in fact a heterogeneous construct. There is no "Cheburnet", but there are "Cheburnets". The experiences of Runet largely depend on the regions where users live, as well as on their ethnicity, their political views and online cultures. We argue that a region's resilience to shutdowns (but also to mainstream propaganda) correlates with the amount of Autonomous System Numbers and the diversity of the ISP market (and disparities in distribution of those are also historically grounded in the "soviet project"). We propose to analyze information control and censorship in terms of "experience", as it impacts interactions between humans, affects their lives on a daily basis and therefore shapes the worlds they live in. Our talk is using a rich ethnographic material to show how people describe problems they encounter with connectivity (especially since Russia has started its war on VPNs). We invite VPN providers and circumvention tool developers to embrace users' perceptions and feelings about what means "working" and what means "not working". While in the network measurement space it is common to either rely on remote measurements, or on probes run by volunteers inside their networks, there is also a qualitative part that should be taken into account to provide a more human-centric, more realistic analysis of what users on the ground experience while interacting with their devices. This talk is also a call against resignation, a call for hackers, VPN providers, circumvention tech developers and Internet freedom activists to actively support indigenous struggles inside "russia" and take into consideration multitudes of experiences within the so-called umbrella "runet".

Additional information

Live Stream https://streaming.media.ccc.de/37c3/granville
Type lecture
Language English

More sessions

12/27/23
Ethics, Politics & Society
Saal 1
Endlich wieder zuhause - endlich wieder in CCH! Wenn das ZPS so etwas wie ein Zuhause hat, dann ist es auf jeden Fall der CCC-Kongress. Natürlich haben wir eine neue Aktion im Gepäck und laden Euch zu einem spannenden Blick hinter die Kulissen ein.
12/27/23
Ethics, Politics & Society
Eva Wolfangel
Saal Granville
Chatbots lassen sich durch Sprache manipulieren. Und Sprache, das ist etwas, das wir Menschen gut können! Das ist eine gute Nachricht. In diesem Talk soll es darum gehen, unsere Ohnmacht zu lindern und zu verstehen, dass wir ziemlich vieles gut können, was uns hilft, große Sprachmodelle für unsere Zwecke zu nutzen (und möglicherweise anders, als sie gedacht sind). Social Engineering und – quatschen.
12/27/23
Ethics, Politics & Society
Saal Zuse
Dieses Jahr konnten wir erstmals im Detail nachvollziehen, wie invasiv und kleinteilig uns Werbefirmen und Datenhändler im Netz kategorisieren. Denn Microsofts Datenmarktplatz Xandr hat versehentlich ein riesiges Dokument veröffentlicht, das ungeahnte Einblicke hinter die Kulissen die Werbeindustrie erlaubt. In der Folge haben mehrere Datenschutzbehörden aus Deutschland und der EU mitgeteilt, die betroffenen Firmen und ihr Geschäft zu prüfen. Aller Cookie-Müdigkeit zum Trotz zeigt unsere ...
12/27/23
Ethics, Politics & Society
Saal 1
Digital Identity Systems proliferate worldwide without any regard for their human rights impact or privacy concerns. Driven by governments and the crony capitalist solutionism peddled by the private sector, official statistics estimate that 80 % of the world’s population is condemned to use them by the end of this decade. These identification systems are a frontal attack on anonymity in the online world, might lead to completely new forms of tracking and discrimination and they are a gift to ...
12/27/23
Ethics, Politics & Society
Anne Roth
Saal Zuse
Was hat sich in den letzten fünf Jahren seit dem letzten Talk über Digitale Gewalt in Deutschland getan? Das Thema stand im Ampel-Koalitionsvertrag, aber was es jetzt geben soll, ist ein Accountsperren-Gesetz, das eine Gefahr für die Anonymität im Netz sein könnte. Das Justizministerium möchte Digitale Gewalt gegen Unternehmen bestrafen ("Restaurantkritik"), aber wer weiterhin im Regen steht: Betroffene und Beratungsstellen. Was hat sich geändert, was nicht und warum müssen wir immer ...
12/27/23
Ethics, Politics & Society
Holger Stark
Saal 1
In diesem Talk wird Holger Stark einen Überblick geben, was juristisch der Stand der Dinge im Fall Assange ist und warum dieser Fall einem Vernichtungsfeldzug gleicht. Er wird anhand bislang unbekannter Aufnahmen einen Blick hinter die Kulissen der US-Regierung werfen – und erklären, warum sich viele Medien mit Solidarität so schwer tun.
12/28/23
Ethics, Politics & Society
Saal Granville
Kein Zebrastreifen ist illegal. Oder doch? Die scheinbar einfache Frage nach der Gesetzeskonformität von Zebrastreifen verursachte mysteriöses Schweigen in der öffentlichen Verwaltung der Stadt Luxemburg. Als Reaktion auf die Datenverweigerung schufen die Aktivist:innen des Zentrums für Urbane Gerechtigkeit eine Mischung aus Google Maps und Tinder, um die benötigten Daten selbst zu generieren. Dieser Vortrag beleuchtet das spannende Zusammenspiel von intransparenten Verwaltungen, der ...